All we want to do is remove the option circled in red, full stop.
We WANT 'shipping' enabled so the customer can choose Pick Up, and for myself, we have multiple locations, they can choose where to pickup.
By marking the product as not physical, this entire screen is gone, but make a Shipping Rate 'Pick Up', the customer still can think it is being shipped, as they entered their address, also with this, they can't choose which store to pick up as.
EDIT: I may have fixed it, browser cookies may have been causing the issue. Clearing everything and starting from scratch, only Pick Up options are shown now.