Thanks for reaching out today. To my understanding, it sounds like you need a feasible way to know exactly which orders are going to be delivered/picked-up in-store on a given date and time.
You would need to utilize a third-party app to integrate this into your Shop. Luckily, there is a terrific app called "Store Pickup + Delivery" that will allow you to organize your orders to your exact needs.
With this app, you will be able to give your customers the option to pick up the order in store, have it locally delivered, or both! The app also has some great features such as a flexible shipping calendar with blackout dates, advanced notice, and future order restrictions. The app is a paid subscription, billed at $29 per month. What you could do is use it for the month of January for $29 and uninstall it after the holiday season is up.
I hope that helps. If there is anything else I can help you with, please let me know.
Hi James, did you ever find a workable solution for this? My shop is same as yours, and I need a way to see all items ordered for pickup/delivery, both kitchen and butcher, so I can give them a list of what needs to be prepared. Exporting the order/drafts, is not very helpful because it shows the customer info and notes field (which is where i'm thinking to put the pickup date) on one line and the lines below show only the item info, with no customer info on that line, so sorting by item shows what we need to prepare, but not who it is for.