Distinguishing between "On Hand" and "Drop Ship" when a customer searches our website

[CathyFAJ]

We sell watches in our physical store as well as drop shipping them from the supplier. I have a bolded caption at the top off the description to identify the drop ship watches, however I can't make  the "actually at our store watches" show up when a customer searches for in store items- all the watches show up.

Does anybody have any suggestions?

We are using Debut theme