This is an accepted solution.
Thanks so much for your question!
There are definitely a couple of reasons you might only be seeing the one pickup option available at a time. For example, in order for a location to appear at all, all items in the cart must have available inventory at that location. In the example you've shared below, are the products in your cart only available at your "Amitai Gindel" location? Or should they be available at your "Michael Kammer" location as well? You can confirm your products' availability by visiting Products > Inventory in your admin and selecting each location at a time. Let me know what you find!
If you're curious, our help doc Local pickup for online orders: Checkout experience goes into more detail on the factors that determine which (if any) locations appear as pickup options at checkout.
So glad to hear it!
Please don't hesitate to let us know if you run into any questions or challenges as you begin to accept orders for pickup. This video tutorial, How to fulfill local pickup orders, is also always available as a refresher on this unique workflow. Enjoy!