Issue with Gift Cards (purchased but not appearing in dashboard)

[KREAMKimchi]

I had a customer who has previously purchased a gift card having issues accessing a gift card they just purchased. I don't see if in the gift card dashboard. I do see her order and looked at the email they received and even clicked "resend gift card" but there still hasn't been a gift card received. I looked up the payment which was made via PayPal checkout. Any tips to finding this gift card and sending it to the customer? Thank you. 

Gift card was purchased December 13th at 5:58 pm via PayPal checkout. thanks.