Figured it out with the help of this post!!!!Go to Orders, Filter by Status, and select open. When it generates your order list here, mark all the orders that are done, click on actions and click on Archive Orders!My counter is FINALLY RIGHT!!!https:...

I even use the "Mark As Fulfilled" button and it does nothing. Why is that button an option? 

But that doesn't take it out of the "unfullfilled" status and it keeps it in our count of orders to fulfill. I have 23 refund, canceled, UNFULLFILLED orders that linger in my order count and it is driving me crazy.  

Has anyone figured this out yet? I feel like I did at one point, but I have 23 canceled, refund, UNFULFILLED orders still showing in my Order count and its driving me CRAZY!!!!