KR3, I am wondering if you might be able to explain better steps 1-3? I find it a little confusing. I really want to understand point by point where exactly you are. Thank you for obliging!  

I think it is a brilliant idea that PayPal is offered first because that means $0 transaction fees for store owners!

Maybe you might try duplicating the order using the duplicate option in the drop-down menu for the original order, then tag it with "R" for replacement.