Can you post on here how you got rid of it?  I am on with Shopify support right now.  This "Shop Pay" add-on is absolute garbage.

This issue is still happening in May of 2024.  This is not a good product to endorse and does not work as expected.  This software should be removed from Shopify add-on center until this has been 100% corrected.  This is me wasting time with tech sup...

I am having the same issue.  It is uninstalled and inactivate but not going away.  I would NOT RECOMMEND Shop pay to anyone. I have the option UN-Checked here... Yet it is still showing "select payment option" here.