Hi @Problembaker ,
Take a look at the Easify Product Options appfor managing your cookie options. This app enables customers to choose their favorite cookies and specify the quantity for each selected type. Additionally, you have the flexibility to set the total number of cookies or establish a maximum limit on the number of cookie types customers can select, tailoring the setup to fit your store’s requirements 
.
Below is an example:
- Storefront:
- App Settings:
If you need help with setup, just reach out to Easify team via in-app live chat 
!