Bundle and subscription plugin suggestions

Shopify Apps
,

Topic summary

A store owner selling jigsaw puzzles seeks an app solution for two key features: bundling multiple puzzles with discounts (e.g., buy 2, save 20%/£10) and creating a subscription service that sends random puzzles monthly/quarterly without duplicates.

App Recommendations:

  • For bundles/upsells: OSCP Bundle & Upsell, Fast Bundle, and BOGOS (Free Gifts, Discounts & Bundles) are suggested
  • For subscriptions: Appstle Subscriptions, Recharge Subscriptions, and Bold Subscriptions are mentioned

Important Technical Limitation:
One respondent highlights a critical compatibility issue: Shopify’s bundle apps don’t work well with subscription apps, citing official Shopify developer documentation. They recommend using Shopify Functions-based discount apps combined with basic Shopify Subscriptions + Flows for the subscription component.

Alternative Approach:
Instead of full automation, starting with customer-selected subscriptions (rather than randomization) is suggested to save time and money, with randomization added later as the business grows.

The discussion remains open with offers for further technical assistance.

Summarized with AI on October 31. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.
1

Hello,

I am building a store selling jigsaw puzzles, so 1 product type with an unlimited possibility of variations/skus. I am looking for a plugin that will help me do the following:

  1. bundle/upsell jigsaw puzzles together possibly from the same collection - eg. Bundle 2 jigsaws and get 20% off/save £10

  2. set up a monthly or quarterly subscription model which would send the customer a random puzzle from my inventory and keep track of that so they don’t get the same puzzle twice

Thank you, any help would be much appreciated :+1:

2

Hi @Sammy_puzzle ,

You’re looking for a Shopify app that can:

  1. Bundle & Upsell – Allow customers to bundle jigsaw puzzles (possibly from the same collection) and get a discount (e.g., buy 2, save £10).
  2. Subscription Model – Set up a monthly/quarterly subscription that sends a random puzzle while ensuring no repeats.

For bundles & upsells, consider:

For subscriptions, consider:

  • Appstle Subscriptions
  • Recharge Subscriptions
  • Bold Subscriptions
1 Like
3

Hi @Sammy_puzzle

You can try BOGOS: Free Gifts, Discounts & Bundles to set up your bundle offer effortlessly. With BOGOS, you can:

  • Create bundles from the same collection
  • Apply discounts – either a percentage (e.g., 20% off) or a fixed amount (e.g., save £10)
  • Customize everything – from colors and layouts to the bundle logic, ensuring it fits perfectly with your store’s design

Bonus: The app is designed for flexibility, so you can tweak your bundles like you want to maximize conversions. Plus, our 24/5 live chat support is always available to help you get set up smoothly!

:pushpin: Here’s how it can look in your store

EllieBOGOS_0-1736926751966.png
EllieBOGOS_0-1736926751966.png793×549 65.3 KB

:rocket: Install BOGOS app here (4,9 overall rating, 2500+ reviews)

1 Like
4

Hey @Sammy_puzzle , there’s a bunch of responses here, and they lack a bit of nuance and you’ll find out Bundle apps do not play well with subscriptions.

It’s documented in thier dev docs. I’ve attached the link for your reading

https://shopify.dev/docs/apps/build/product-merchandising/bundles#limitations

Abel_Lesle_0-1740176993452.png
Abel_Lesle_0-1740176993452.png2880×1614 535 KB

For the bundle builder aspect, you can set it up as follows using any Shopify functions based discount app (we have an app that does this) + a bit of customisation in your collection page which can be done fairly easily.

  1. On our app, you’d set up a rule in our configurator which goes like - If customer buys 2 jigsaws on subscription, get X$ / % off for those items.
  2. Then comes the subscription part, it’s possible to set up this experience using the most basic Shopify subscription app + Flows if you have some technical chops
    • Else you’ll need an alternative that solves for the randomisation aspect - most don’t. But I suggest letting the user choose just to start with and then building the randomisation aspect as you go. You’ll save a lot of time and money this way.

Your question was super easy for me to understand and the way you presented it was also straightforward, Our team has experience working in the discounts, loyalty and subscription space and would be happy to help further if required.

Feel free to reach out if you have any queries / questions.

Regards

5

Hi @Sammy_puzzle :raising_hands:

If you want to create jigsaw puzzle bundles and offer quantity-based discounts, you can use Easify Box Builder —a completely free app that’s perfectly suited for puzzle shops like yours.

  • This is the result:

image
image1600×923 311 KB

  • This is the result:

You can name your box, choose the box type and template — we offer a wide variety of designs, and of course, you’re free to customize them however you like.

image
image1600×1078 180 KB

Then, you’ll be taken to the Visual Editor, where you can select your products and customize every part of the product page.

image
image1600×796 256 KB

Next, open the Discount & Subscription tab and set up your pricing rules exactly the way you want:

image
image1600×797 231 KB

Next, to activate the subscription feature (setting up monthly or quarterly billing models), scroll down to the Subscription section, switch the status to Enable, and select your preferred plan. (It will automatically sync your subscription plans from the connected external app.)

image
image1600×792 267 KB

I hope this answer helps solve your problem!

There’s a list of subscription apps that work with Easify — contact us if you’re interested. And if you need any further assistance, feel free to reach out to Easify anytime! :smiling_face: