Challenges with a US store that sells in a foreign currency

Start a Business

Topic summary

A US-based Shopify store selling primarily to Australian customers in AUD faces several operational challenges:

Payment & Checkout Issues:

  • AfterPay unavailable because store currency (AUD) doesn’t match store location (US) per platform requirements
  • Instagram Checkout not supported for US stores selling in foreign currencies, preventing product tagging in Instagram posts

Customer Experience Problems:

  • Australian customers receive “international transaction” warnings from credit card providers despite purchasing in AUD, which may discourage sales
  • The mismatch between US location and Australian currency creates friction that feels inconsistent to local buyers

Key Question:
The poster seeks advice on how other US-based stores successfully serve international markets while maintaining seamless local appearance and access to features like AfterPay. They’re uncertain whether they’re missing a configuration solution or if these are inherent platform limitations when operating cross-border with foreign currency settings.

Summarized with AI on November 10. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.
1

We are a store with our location in the US. But we sell primarily to Australia, and our sore currency is AUD.

This creates some problems

  1. No AfterPay: AfterPay is not available if your store currency is different to your Store location (docs https://developers.afterpay.com/docs/api/platforms/shopify/getting-started : “The store currency must correspond to the Afterpay account region“)
  2. Australian customers can get warnings from their credit card provider that buying from us is an “international transaction.” This can deter them from purchasing: if you are an Australian, buying something in AUD, and you get a warning from your bank that you are making an “international purchase” then it feels wrong.
  3. Issues with Meta integration: Instagram Checkout is not supported for US Stores that sell in other currencies (https://help.instagram.com/951629962247940) (and image below). No Checkout means no Store, and no Store means we are unable to tag our products in our IG posts.

These are some of the issues we have. Are we missing something? How do other US-based stores do international so they have features like AfterPay, and so it appears seamless and local to foreign markets?

thanks for a any tips!

Screenshot 2024-04-24 at 10.21.19 PM.png
Screenshot 2024-04-24 at 10.21.19 PM.png1540×1306 281 KB