Change Free Shipping Method?

Topic summary

A merchant discovered that customers qualifying for free shipping (orders over $100) could select premium options like overnight air at no charge, instead of being limited to standard ground shipping.

Solutions proposed:

  • One suggestion involved using the PluginHive Multi-Carrier Shipping Label app to restrict free shipping to specific carrier options, though this requires a carrier account and enabling Carrier Calculated Shipping (CCS) in Shopify.

  • The original poster found a workaround by deleting their free shipping rate and creating an “economy shipping” rate with a $100 minimum order value instead. This approach limits customers to only the intended shipping method when qualifying for free shipping.

Related issue:

Another participant mentioned a different concern about free shipping appearing as the default option at checkout (rather than restricting which methods qualify), which Shopify support indicated might require custom coding to resolve.

Summarized with AI on October 31. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

Hello! We offer free shipping on our store for orders over $100 within the US. However, a customer recently let us know that they had the option to select any shipping option, including overnight air, for free. How do I change it so that they can only select like, USPS ground for free shipping? Thanks so much!

Hi @Seirye !

Shopify’s native settings don’t allow for restricting free shipping to specific options.

However, you can achieve this by using the PluginHive Multi-Carrier Shipping Label app. With this app, you can connect your carrier account with shopify and set up an automation rule to manage free shipping:

  • Orders under $100 show carrier rates at checkout.
  • Orders over $100 display only the free shipping option.

Once set up, this system will only show the standard free shipping option at Shopify checkout for eligible orders over $100.
Additionally for label printing, you can set ‘UPS Ground’ as the default service for orders over $100, ensuring the correct label is generated seamlessly.

[ Note: To make this possible with the application, there are two requirements: having your carrier account and enabling the Carrier Calculated Shipping (CCS) feature in Shopify to display rates at checkout. ]

If anyone is curious, I figured out a solution after a couple days of playing and with help from this reply! I deleted our free shipping, added a rate for economy shipping, and set the minimum price to $100 (our minimum price for free shipping in the US). Hope this helps someone else!

Hi Thanks for the reply. I use Shipx and the free shipping comes from cart total over £70. It now sits at the top of Shipping method. Ship x say it is controlled from the Shopify side. I sometimes have 3 choices and they are governed by lowest cost on top, and therefore free will always be on top.

Hi Thanks for the reply. I use Shipx and the free shipping comes from cart total over £70. It now sits at the top of Shipping method. Shipx say it is controlled from the Shopify side. I sometimes have 3 choices and they are governed by lowest cost on top, and therefore free will always be on top.

i was told by Shopify that it could be done by someone who understands coding. Sopify also said try the forum.

Hi, i have got free shipping, it is that Free shipping is the default when I have other choices. I was told by Shopify that it could be done by someone who understands coding. Sopify also said try the forum.