Collection - Manual product sort order keeps resetting in backoffice

Topic summary

Manual product sort order in Shopify collections does not persist: after being set to “Manually,” the order reverts within minutes (reported as 5–10 minutes) to an unexpected sequence, with one user noting it switches back to “Newest.”

Key points:

  • Affected setting: Collection sort set to “Manually,” then auto-resets without user action.
  • Observed behavior: Reversion to “Newest” or a seemingly random order after a short time.
  • Scope: Confirmed by multiple users; at least one specific collection affected for another user.
  • Impact: Admin/backoffice sorting becomes unreliable; users seek reason why Shopify overrides their settings.
  • Context: Frustration expressed; one participant characterizes it as a Shopify bug. No official explanation or workaround provided.

Status: No resolution or actionable guidance in the thread; issue remains open/ongoing.

Summarized with AI on December 15. AI used: gpt-5.

Can someone help please. I keep setting manual sort order for products in a collection but it just reverts to some random selection within 5,10 minutes by itself.

Why does Shopify override my settings?

3 Likes

We face the same issue here in one of our collections.
We set the collection to be sorted manually but after a few minutes goes back to “Newest”.
Any help would be much appreciated.

1 Like

Bump.

Yet another annoying Shopify bug that shows they clearly test nothing.

Add it to the ever growing list, including inserting blog images no longer allowing size changes before inserting, adding an extra step to every single image insert.