Dealing with potential spam in abandoned carts: should I be concerned?

Topic summary

Multiple Shopify merchants are experiencing a widespread bot attack creating fake abandoned carts and fraudulent orders, primarily using the name “James James” and email addresses ending in @rtremail.com or similar domains. The issue has escalated significantly since late January 2024, with some stores reporting 5,000+ abandoned carts in days and hundreds of fake orders.

Key characteristics of the attack:

  • Bots target $0.00 products specifically
  • Some merchants report actual orders being placed and marked as “paid” without payment
  • Attacks bypass Google reCAPTCHA and standard spam protections
  • Bots create customer accounts through a backend vulnerability
  • Pattern evolved from “James James” to randomized same first/last names

Impact on merchants:

  • Cluttered abandoned cart reports making real customers hard to identify
  • Corrupted analytics and email reputation scores
  • Issues with accounting/CRM software imports
  • Inability to use $0 products for legitimate marketing purposes

Proposed solutions (mostly ineffective):

  • Shopify support suggests enabling reCAPTCHA and third-party paid apps (Negate, Shop Protector, Ellipsis)
  • Only reliable workaround: disabling all $0 products (unacceptable for many)
  • One user suggests pre-registering bot email addresses with strong passwords

Current status: The issue remains unresolved months later. Merchants express frustration that Shopify hasn’t provided a built-in solution and are considering switching platforms. Shopify reportedly acknowledged the issue but hasn’t prioritized a fix.

Summarized with AI on October 24. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

Need some sort of solution for this. If go into your email app and look at the abandoned checkout emails it hurts the email reputation scores.

1 Like