Email Forwarding - Email forwarding is not allowed for this domain

Topic summary

Users purchasing new domains through Shopify are encountering an error when attempting to add MX records for third-party email providers (primarily Zoho and Google Workspace): “Email forwarding is not allowed for this domain.”

Root Cause:
Starting December 2024, Shopify disabled the Email Hosting & Forwarding feature for all new domain purchases as part of a platform update to “streamline services and improve overall performance.”

Resolution Process:

  • This is not a user-fixable issue and requires Shopify support intervention
  • Users must contact Shopify support via live chat to request manual re-enablement
  • Support escalates cases to technical teams who restore the feature on a per-domain basis
  • Resolution typically takes 2-5 minutes once connected with the right support agent, though some cases require escalation and longer wait times

Workarounds:

  • Switch to CloudFlare nameservers and manage DNS records there (requires technical knowledge)
  • For Zoho specifically: Navigate to Domains → Email Forwarding → “Switch to email hosting” → Select Zoho Mail and enter only the verification code portion

Current Status:
No platform-wide fix announced. Each affected user must individually contact support for manual resolution.

Summarized with AI on October 28. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

Any update?