I have to admit I’m pretty surprised that Shopify has not addressed this already. Getting notified of new subscribers seems like one of the most basic needs any store owner would have, and I hope that the Shopify team can put some attention to this because I’m currently in this predicament too, and installing 3rd party apps to do simple functions is more confusing than it really should be
Topic summary
-
Goal: Get notified when a customer subscribes to the store’s mailing list.
-
Current platform behavior: Shopify’s built‑in customer list (via theme email signup) does not send admin notifications. Staff suggested third‑party apps (e.g., Advanced Admin Email Alerts, Notifications) and noted a feature request has been submitted; progress can only be seen via the public changelog.
-
Community feedback: Multiple merchants requested native notifications and expressed frustration about relying on apps.
-
Latest workable solution (no app): Use Shopify Marketing Automations to self‑notify. Create a custom automation with trigger “Customer created” and action “Send internal email,” or add an internal email step to your welcome sequence. A screenshot was shared illustrating this setup.
-
Open questions/gaps: No guidance on notifications for unsubscribes. Another merchant asked for easier, incremental export of only new subscriber emails (currently done via manual CSV handling).
-
Status: No native feature confirmed; automation workaround or apps are the current options. Discussion remains open.
6 Likes