Feedback Needed For My Store

[Mackiejc]

Hello Everyone,

I have had a store on Shopify for years now (mypurebotanical.com), and it has gone through loads of revisions. I am very happy with how my store looks now, but despite getting up to 60 views per day from my ad campaigns and organic traffic, it takes up to 2 months to get an order. My products are a lower price point than most competitors and are of the highest quality on the market. One of my undergraduate degrees are in marketing, yet I am totally stumped. Am I missing something?

[BiDeal-Discount]

Hi @Mackiejc

Welcome to our community & thank you for your sharing your business.

I see your site look good but if you still get less sales you should consider to setup bundle discounts, maybe increase the original price to push discount strategy.
Maybe like:

• Buy 2 get 5% off, Buy 5 get 15% off

• Order subtotal is greater than $1000 will get free shipping

• Order subtotal is greater than $1200 will get free gift

• Order subtotal is greater than $1500 will get 10% off

• Mix and match a bundle to have a discount price. Eg: mix product Flower Power & product Forest Friends to a bundle then put a price like $88

All of them can get more attractive from clients. Why shouldn’t you do?
I’m founder of BiDeal Bundle Volume Discount app - an app resolve every issue I list a bove. It’s free at the moment so you can try it out.

Let me know if you need any assistance.

Thanks!

[DaisyVo]

Hi @Mackiejc ,

To address SEO challenges, I recommend using the AVADA SEO Suite , a comprehensive tool designed to optimize Shopify stores.

Here’s how it can benefit your website:

• Image Optimization: Compresses images without compromising quality, enhancing site speed.

• Meta Tag Management: Automates the creation and optimization of meta titles and descriptions, improving search engine rankings.

• Structured Data Implementation: Adds JSON-LD structured data, facilitating rich snippets in search results.

• SEO Audits: Provides detailed audits to identify and rectify SEO issues.

• Keyword Analysis: Offers insights into relevant keywords, aiding in content optimization

- Our app offers a free trial for Pro and Enterprise plans. You can check it out as our app provides a free trial for Pro and Enterprise plans. https://apps.shopify.com/avada-seo-suite?utm_source=Shopify_Community&utm_medium=Daisy

If you have any questions or need assistance with installation and setup, please feel free to contact us. We’re happy to help!

Best regards,
DaisyVo

[Jenny6]

Hi @Mackiejc

I notice your current situation and would like to do something for you with the feedback you need on the store. Through my page speed test, I notice the different scores existing on your website via phone port and desktop port. Here are the details below, please kindly check:

https://pagespeed.web.dev/analysis/https-www-mypurebotanical-com/adnxletxyp?form_factor=mobile

The speed test score on desktop port is much higher than the one on phone port. This means you must pay a lot of efforts and attention on desktop previously, but lack of further optimizations on phone port accordingly. If your users prefer to access product pages via phone port, the slow page speed will affect your conversions and shorten the time of staying on your web pages for some users. Therefore, please pay more attentions on page speed on desktop and mobile both. So far, the factor affecting your page speed on mobile is LCP element mainly, you can check this guideline from Google to learn more about LCP status and get support from developers for further optimization on page speed mainly. Thank you!

[MooseDesk]

Hi @Mackiejc ,

Thanks for reaching out to the community. We are MooseDesk, a comprehensive Live Chat, FAQ & Helpdesk App designed to elevate your customer support experience.

Your store has quite enough essential information. However, if you want to make it more convertible, please check my recommendations below.

1. Add a favicon

Adding a favicon can indeed contribute to converting visitors to shoppers, although its impact might be more subtle than other elements. It helps users quickly reorient themselves if they accidentally navigate away, potentially salvaging sales

2. Freeze the menu bar

A sticky header makes it easier for users to find what they’re looking for and avoid having to scroll back to the top each time they want to navigate to a different website section.

3. Enhance the footer section

The footer is often overlooked, but it’s a valuable piece that can significantly enhance user experience and boost your website’s effectiveness. Some of the elements you can consider adding are:

• Copyright notice: Clearly state the copyright owner and year.
• Privacy policy link: Link to your detailed privacy policy.
• Terms of service link: Link to your terms and conditions.
• Contact information: Include your address, phone number, and email.
• Social media icons: Link to your social media profiles

4. Add a search bar to the FAQ page

A search bar will help your customers find relevant information quickly without having to scroll down all the way to the bottom.

5. Add a live chat widget

Live chat assists potential customers instantly, addressing their questions or concerns in real time. This can prevent abandonment and encourage purchases.

I suggest exploring MooseDesk, a free live chat, FAQ & Helpdesk App. MooseDesk provides auto-reply features during non-business hours, a proactive help center, and a user-friendly widget layout, offering an effective solution to enhance customer support on your platform.

——

As an expert/enthusiast in UX, I recommend implementing these changes to improve customer experience when scrolling through your store.

If this is helpful for you, please let me know by giving me a ‘LIKE’. If your question is answered please mark this as 'SOLUTION’.

Thank you for reading. Wish you a nice day ahead!

MooseDesk - All-in-one Shopify FAQ & Helpdesk App

[Bundler-Manuel]

Hello there @Mackiejc I just had a look at your store and I want to first commend you for making such a unique selection in terms of the product you are using. In terms of how to improve the store itself, here are some areas I’ve identified

1. You should have a sticky header with the search button icon on it to make it much easier for customers to navigate through your store.

2. The customer reviews on the homepage are well detailed but it would be a good idea to add photos and maybe the occupations of the people giving the reviews so that they appear much more authentic than they do at the moment.

3. Add a FAQ page on the homepage as well where you can go into more details on information like the materials you use for the products, etc.

[PieLab]

Hi there @Mackiejc . It’s clear you’ve put in time & care, and you’re very passionate about the quality of your products

From looking through your store, I feel that the core issue isn’t your pricing or product quality, but it’s about trust and presentation. Right now, the store design doesn’t reflect enough level of professionalism and credibility that your brand deserves at all, unfortunately. If you wouldn’t mind, I will take a few issues below as example:

- First impressions feel unfinished: The hero section (and homepage, in general) feels minimal and unfinished. There’s no clear brand story, no strong value hook, and the visual styling doesn’t reflect the care that’s clearly behind your formulas. For wellness shoppers, esp. cold traffic from ads, emotional trust may be everything.

- Header menu: Right now, it includes a single dropdown ‘Catalog’ menu, which doesn’t really help guide the visitors or encourage browsing. A visitor landing from your ads may not know where to go next. You can consider organizing header menu into specific collections to improve navigation and communicate the confidence and purpose of your products.

- Product pages lack structure and persuasion: While your product descriptions are informative, they are displayed as unformatted text blocks. Also, there’s no use of images, trust badges, reviews, etc. to guide the visitor’s decision. This might cause the visitors to hesitate and hurt conversion even when someone is interested.

- No urgency reminder: Shoppers don’t see signals like “Best Seller”, “Low Stock”, etc. There’s no reinforcement that your brand is legitimate or that your products are in demand.

I strongly recommend investing in a professional theme or design refresh. For the last issue, if you’d like a quick win, I’d also recommend using the DECO Product Labels & Badges app to highlight things like “Best Seller”, “Low Stock”, “30% OFF”, etc. across your collections and product pages.

You’ve already got the hard part - the products themselves and now it’s just time to give them the store they deserve. Cheers!

[Akohub]

Hi, I’m Wayne from Akohub. We have been working with many brands to run online stores. After viewing your website, I believe our expertise could add value to your business.

Several merchants who worked with us also faced the same challenges as yours- getting traffics but few conversions. One area that often makes a significant difference is retargeting, which is designed to bring back those visitors who leave without making a purchase. It works by keeping your brand top-of-mind as people continue browsing the web, gently reminding them of what they left behind in your store. By focusing your marketing efforts on people who have already shown interest, you’re far more likely to see a return on your ad spend.

To streamline the work of launching retargeting campaigns, check out our Ako Marketing app. It lets you set up retargeting ads for Facebook, Instagram, and Google right from your Shopify admin, helping you recover abandoned carts and convert more visitors into buyers.

Best wishes! If you have any more questions or need a free professional consultation, feel free to let us know! Don’t forget to like and mark it as a solution if you find this helpful.

[BON_Loyalty]

Hi @Mackiejc ! It’s Tracy here from BON.

Thanks for sharing your story—your store looks great, and it’s clear you’ve put a ton of work into it. Totally understand how frustrating it can be to get consistent traffic but very few conversions. From what we’ve seen at BON (we help Shopify merchants build loyalty programs to boost repeat purchases), this situation actually comes up a lot. Here are a few things that might help:

1. Start by reviewing traffic quality
60 visits a day is decent, but the real question is: are they the right visitors? Dive into your traffic sources and consider using heatmaps (like Hotjar or Microsoft Clarity) to see where people focus—or drop off. A bit of A/B testing on product pages or banners might reveal what resonates better with your audience.

2. It’s normal that people don’t buy right away
Especially with wellness or botanical products, the decision process can take time. What you need is trust + urgency. Map out your customer journey—from first visit to purchase—and look for friction points. Is there enough social proof? Is it clear why someone should buy now?

3. Build ongoing relationships
A one-time visit often isn’t enough. Consider running a small email capture campaign (like a popup with a first-time offer) and build a list of genuinely interested leads. Then nurture them with emails about your brand story, benefits of your products, or tips on how to use them.

4. Add social proof + live chat
Even just a few customer reviews or real-life product photos can make a huge difference in building confidence. A live chat tool also helps answer those quick questions that might otherwise cause people to leave.

Lastly, if you haven’t already, this might be a great time to think about a loyalty or referral program. I recommend checking out BON Loyalty, a user-friendly, powerful, all-in-one loyalty solution designed specifically for Shopify stores. Rewarding small actions like email signups, product shares, or first purchases can not only improve conversion—it also brings people back. Hope this gives you a clearer direction! You’ve already got the product and presentation nailed—it’s just about tightening the journey from visitor to customer.

[Mackiejc]

Thank you so much, this is very helpful! I will be implementing these changes as soon as possible. I greatly appreciate your feedback!

[PieLab]

My pleasure, @Mackiejc . Feel free to ask any questions if you need help anytime soon. Happy selling!

[Tapita-support2]

Hi @Mackiejc ! Getting 60 views daily but only one order every 2 months suggests a serious conversion issue rather than a traffic problem. Despite your marketing background and store revisions, there are still some fundamental gaps affecting sales.

Key Conversion Issues:

• Missing Sales Psychology: Even with competitive pricing, customers often need urgency triggers. Consider implementing sales, limited-time offers, or promotional pricing to create purchasing motivation. Sometimes the absence of any promotional activity makes customers wait for “better deals.”
• Product Organization: Your individual product listings could benefit from being grouped together as variants of main products. This approach improves SEO, creates more comprehensive product pages, and helps customers easily compare options within your product lines.
• Content Gap: Without blog content, you’re missing opportunities to build trust, educate customers about botanical benefits, and attract organic traffic from people researching natural products - a key audience for botanical items.
• Technical SEO: Many of your pages appear to be missing optimized meta titles and descriptions, which impacts both search visibility and click-through rates from search results.
• Trust Building: Botanical products often require more education and trust-building than other categories since customers want to understand benefits and quality.

To address these conversion barriers efficiently: G: Combined Listings & Variant offers a free plan for better product organization. Tapita AI SEO Blog Builder is completely free and perfect for creating educational botanical content. Tapita: SEO Optimizer & Speed provides a comprehensive free plan for fixing meta data and technical SEO issues.

With your traffic level, small conversion improvements could dramatically increase sales!

Tapita Team

[Nemanja_Janjic]

hi @Mackiejc

Just took a look at mypurebotanical.com and honestly, the site looks great. I really like the clean style and the product selection. That said, here are 3 things that could make it even better:

1. Product Page – Trust Badges
   I didn’t notice any clear trust indicators (like shipping, badges). A trust badge widget like TrustMark could help boost buyer confidence.

2. Product Page – Key Features Layout
   The key features are informative but appear in large blocks of text. A more visual layout (icons, bullet points, or graphics) could improve readability and engagement.

3. Site Speed
   The loading time could be optimized. A faster site = better UX and higher conversions.

Small tweaks, but they can make a big difference.

Cheers,

Nemanja

[kalyanwaytoapps]

Hi @Mackiejc

I visited My Pure Botanical, and you’ve built a really clean and trustworthy-looking store. The natural, health-conscious vibe is clear, and your product prices are very accessible compared to competitors. That’s a great starting point. That said, if you’re getting consistent traffic but orders only trickle in every couple of months, here are some areas to focus on:

1. Strengthen Trust & Social Proof
Right now, I don’t see much in terms of reviews, testimonials, or user experiences. For health/wellness products, customers want to see that others have had good results.
Try adding reviews on product pages and even a dedicated “Customer Stories” section. Customers are more likely to purchase when they trust the store. You should add product reviews using a tool like ShopReviews ‑ Product Reviews - ShopReviews - Boost your sales with product reviews | Shopify App Store, which makes collecting and displaying real customer feedback seamless
Highlight any certifications, lab testing, or guarantees (money-back, satisfaction, etc.) directly near the “Add to Cart” button.

2. Refine the Product Pages
Descriptions are clean but could be more benefit-focused. Instead of just listing ingredients or features, connect to results: e.g., “Supports relaxation and deeper sleep naturally”.
Use comparison visuals: “Why choose us vs. competitors” — highlight purity, sourcing, and affordability.
Stronger CTAs (calls-to-action) like “Start Your Wellness Journey Today” instead of just “Add to Cart” can make the product feel more valuable.

3. Improve Conversion Flow
Add bundles or upsells (e.g., “Buy 2, Save 10%” or “Wellness Starter Pack”). This increases order size and makes customers feel they’re getting better value.
Use limited-time offers or subtle urgency messages like “Only a few left” or “Sale ends tonight” to nudge hesitant buyers.
Make sure checkout feels frictionless—guest checkout, Shop Pay, and PayPal are must-haves.

4. Content & SEO Leverage
With your background in marketing, a content strategy could set you apart. Blog posts like “Top 5 Botanicals for Stress Relief” or short video explainers could help build organic trust.
Pair this with email signups offering a free wellness guide or discount for first-time buyers to capture leads.

5. Retargeting & Community
If ads are bringing in traffic but not converting, try retargeting campaigns for cart abandoners or visitors who viewed multiple products.
Also consider building a community angle—Instagram, TikTok, or a newsletter where you share botanical wellness tips. It makes your brand feel like a trusted friend, not just a shop.

If you’re also selling on Etsy, consider using an app like Etsy Integration ‑ ShopList - ShopList - seamless integration between Shopify and Etsy | Shopify App Store . It lets you sync your products and orders between Shopify and Etsy automatically, saving time and helping you manage inventory more efficiently—perfect for handmade or customized products like yours.

Best Regards,

Waytoapps

[Dan-From-Ryviu]

Hi @Mackiejc

• You made some mistake on your banner, please check and solve the issue.

• Your site is clean, everything ok but I cannot see product reviews on your store, which could help you increase trust and sales.
• You also can add Buy more save more feature, that could help increase average order value (AOV).
• Have you run retarget and abandoned checkout campaign?

Best regards,

Dan from Ryviu: Reviews & QA