How can I set different prices for multiple material options on the same product?

Hi JM24,

You can create a conditional logic for that.

By using conditional logic you can setup the cost for particular variant of the product.

Find out the best Shopify product customizer app for your e-commerce store.

Smart Product Options:

Smart Product Options is a fantastic tool that allows your customers to creatively design the products they are going to purchase. Unlimited Product Options and Creates an unlimited custom product fields including text, numbers, swatches, checkboxes, dropdown menus, radio buttons, file uploads and more.

Easy to set up, Flexible Conditional Logic, Add-On Pricing, Group Fields into Option Groups and reuse them, Price Add-On’s, Field Types and Support Team