Hey @emccaleb , have you solved this issue for your store?
We’ve actually built an app that stops Honey and other coupon extensions/sites from working and sharing your VIP codes.
https://apps.shopify.com/veeper-app
https://www.veeper.com/
Coupon Blocker™: Blocks auto-applying coupon extensions at your checkout.
Campaign Links™ + Scripts: Replace your coupon codes and inject offers into your pricing. No coupon codes = No leaks.
Smart Discounts™: Apply the smallest discount that gets each customer to convert - boosting AOV by net 14%.
Let me know if you’d like some more info!