The dynamic checkout button is designed to automatically detect the best option for the specific customer viewing your shop, based on a number of factors like the customer’s browser, device, payment history, etc. You can learn more about these factors and the button in general here. Since this is the way the button is designed, there is no way to manually choose which option is shown. While Shop Pay has been proven to increase conversions, if you don’t want Shop Pay appearing to customers, you can disable it by following these steps and it will no longer appear as a payment option. There is no way to have it set up as a payment option, and not have it appear on dynamic checkout buttons. All that being said, if you choose to leave it up as a payment option and it is the option shown to your customer, your customer can still choose their preferred payment option by clicking the More payment options button or continuing to the checkout.
Thank you for the explanation in your reply. I suppose that we will just leave it disabled until shopify comes out with an option to not have it pop up amongst the dynamic checkout buttons. Unfortunately, the dynamic checkout appears to prioritize the shop pay button even when someone does not have the shop pay app, thereby muddying up the smoothness of the checkout process by having them make an account with shop pay as their main option.
It sucks, because well, we would like the traffic from the Shop App customers, but it’s not worth how low it would potentially mess up our conversion rates. Thank you though!
Advertising for Shop and Shop Payments on my product page is absolutely embarrassing. Advertise for this in the checkout section, but not on my PRODUCT PAGE.