Inventory still showing on website even though I've selected "do not track inventory"

Hello.

I am using Debut theme, and for certain products on my website I would like to NOT track quantity. Easy enough, but when I uncheck the “track inventory” box on a product, it still shows whatever inventory on my website that the product was set at before I unchecked that box.

For instance, I’m trying to sell certain yarns “dyed to order” with theoretically unlimited quantities available. So even though a customer can still buy it if the quantity is listed as -5, seeing that makes them think it’s sold out and they won’t try to purchase it. How do I remove shown quantities on my website from products with the “track inventory” box unchecked?

Hey @laurenp1
Can you share your Store URL and password if enabled?