Mix & Match Variants

Topic summary

A merchant selling 4-packs of dog booties needs customers to select different sizes and colors for front and back paws within a single product. Current Shopify variant limits prevent creating separate “front paw” and “back paw” size/color options.

Attempted solutions that failed:

  • Selling in pairs caused confusion (customers thought they were buying 4 boots) and increased exchanges
  • Apps with limitless options don’t track color/size inventory independently and add items at checkout, creating confusion
  • Current mix-and-match app requires pricing individual boots, breaking Facebook/Instagram sales integration and confusing customers

Proposed solutions from community:

  • JTDL Bundles app: Offers “Build Your Own Bundle” feature where customers select from different collections (front left, front right, back left, back right), each containing product variations. Screenshots show bundle-building interface.
  • Easify Product Options app: Adds unlimited custom options to a single product page, allowing front/back paw selections without splitting products. Requires additional setup for inventory tracking per option, but offers 24/7 support.

The merchant seeks affordable solutions without custom development, ideally maintaining proper inventory tracking and checkout clarity.

Summarized with AI on October 27. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

Hoping someone can help as I have been through dozens of apps and have not found the right solution.

We sell a 4-pack of dog booties. Current variants are size and color. We need to be able to offer customer’s the option to choose different sizes and color for front and back paws. So they need to be able to mix and match the variants within that 4-pack.

Things we have already tried:

  • selling in pairs (people get confused and think they are purchasing 4 boots, despite it being plastered all over the product page OR people guess the size and buy a pair instead of measuring so we see a surplus in exchanges)
  • apps that allow limitless options - we need to be able to track color and size inventory independently and none of these work that way. They also add additional items to the cart at checkout, which creates checkout confusion.
  • currently, an app that allows us to mix & match variants, while requiring a minimum purchase of 4. So far this is the best option, but there are limitations. We have had to change the product price to the price of a single boot, which means we can’t sell on FB or IG as the app does not translate. And, it’s not intuitive, people are still getting confused.

If Shopify would just allow for more variants, I think this would solve a lot of our issues as we could have separate “front and back paw sizes”

If anyone has ideas on how we can implement this, without spending thousands of dollars for custom development, I’m all ears! Thanks!

Hello @RMPP !

Can you please provide the URL of your store?

You can try our app: https://apps.shopify.com/jtdl-bundles-discounts
It offers features like Build Your Own Bundles and Quantity Breaks, allowing your customers to mix and match products to create custom sets—perfect for meal deals, beauty kits, outfit bundles, and more.

For combo bundle, you can include different collections (e.g., front left, front right, back left, back right), and within each collection, offer a selection of products.
For example, customers can choose 1 out of 3 boots from the “front left” collection, then continue building their bundle with products from the other collections.

Hi @RMPP

You might want to try Easify Product Options – it lets you add unlimited custom options to your product, so your customers can easily select different sizes and colors for the front and back paws within the same 4-pack.

It keeps everything on one product page and helps avoid the confusion that comes with splitting products or using workarounds. Here’s how it works:

  • This is the result:

  • This is the app setting:

If you want to manage inventory for each item in your option set, there will be a few extra steps to set it up properly. But no worries — just reach out to our 24/7 in-app live chat, and we’ll be happy to guide you through it! :hugs: