New Theme website not showing in Google

I initially started my website using Origin theme in July and at the time when I searched google for the site - it would come up

now the website doesn’t come up at all.. since having changed themes to DWELL… has anyone experiences anything similar to this and what should I review to fix this problem?

Thank you!

Hello and welcome

We are here to help each other

So kindly drop your store URL for the honest feedback

We shall get there

Use Google Business Profile and Google Search Console

Wouldn’t that be useful! it’s atroveofcrafts.com

Okay stay active for the positive feedback

Hello after review your store/solutions

I recommend setting up a Google Knowledge Panel for your website. It helps your brand stand out in search results with verified details, logos, and key links. This increases your site’s trust, visibility, and credibility. When people search your business, they’ll instantly see accurate, professional information making your brand look more established and boosting customer confidence online.

If you have any questions caused I may not active here

Share on WhatsApp

At minimum you’d need to point SEO tools at a preview of the old unpublished version and start making comparisons; even though the data would be technically flawed because of the lack of data OVER TIME when this first started.

If the theme SEO structure was some how involved you’d really need a before and after.
I.e. an SEO audit and similar data ran BEFORE you made a fundamental change to compare AFTER

Without that your swinging in the dark and anyone else is just guessing.

That is not a big indication a theme is at fault.
That only shows that your SEO failed at some point and you were monitoring it.

If the old theme was customized for SEO you need to do the same to the new theme.
if you were using apps, etc etc.

“fix” It by going and engaging an actual SEO expert to repair the damage.
You already messed up once do you think you can avoid doing more damage by doing it alone?

Without deep analysis and actual work , your just gonna repliers/bots just guessing and telling you what you want to hear to try and get a sale.

Bots here are just gonna tell what you want to hear to try and get a sale instead of going and doing the harder expensive work.

Hello, @BPatel_1

The good news is that your site is not invisible to Google. I’ve done a direct check. When you perform a special search on Google using site:atroveofcrafts.com, it shows that Google has indeed indexed several pages from your site, including your homepage, product pages, and policy pages. This is great news because it means there isn’t a fundamental technical block preventing Google from seeing your store.

So, the issue isn’t that your site has disappeared from Google’s index, but rather that its ranking has dropped significantly. When you search for “a trove of crafts,” other, more established sites or those with similar names are currently being seen as more relevant by Google’s algorithm.

Changing a theme can absolutely cause this. While your product URLs and content remain the same, a new theme can change many underlying SEO elements. The DWELL theme might be missing some key optimizations that the Origin theme had, or some settings might need to be re-configured.

Thank You!

Hey,how is business going

Hello, how are you doing …how is business going