Sessions up, sales down. Shopify not taking accountability.

Topic summary

Store owners report a persistent issue since March 2023: sessions have increased significantly while conversion rates have dropped dramatically (from ~2% to below 1% in many cases). The problem appears concentrated at checkout, where more customers reach the payment stage but fewer complete purchases.

Key observations:

  • Multiple merchants experiencing identical patterns starting March 8-March 2023
  • Issue persists despite implementing free shipping, discounts, and site improvements
  • Shopify Analytics shows inflated session counts not reflected in GA4
  • Some customers report checkout failures, but owners cannot replicate the errors
  • Conversion data temporarily disappeared from Shopify’s reporting
  • Bot traffic spikes observed from various countries

Troubleshooting attempts:

  • Testing across multiple devices and browsers
  • Hiring developers to audit code and apps
  • Investigating GA4 migration issues, SEO changes, and payment gateways
  • Checking for JavaScript errors and app conflicts

Shopify’s response:
Support provides generic answers and emphasizes their business model depends on merchant success. They suggest checking abandoned carts, shipping rates, and discount strategies. One moderator mentions Google indexing analytics URLs as a potential cause.

Current status:
No resolution found. Several merchants, including Shopify Plus users doing $1M+ annually, are considering migrating to other platforms due to lack of actionable support and ongoing conversion issues.

Summarized with AI on November 1. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

The role I believe the platform has is an issue with the checkout process. I pulled some data on checkout sessions vs conversions. The number of customers going to checkout has increased but the number then proceeding to complete the transaction has dropped. This leads me to believe there are checkout issues; i have heard this complaint from other store owners as well.

My conversion rate has been above 2% for over a year, but ever since Feb/Mar it’s been around 1%, lower than I’ve ever seen.

2 Likes