Shopify is holding my $12,661.24 for no reason!

Payments + Shipping & Fulfilment

Topic summary

Multiple merchants report having significant funds frozen by Shopify Payments without clear justification, with hold periods ranging from 90-120 days. Amounts range from $4,000 to over $29,000.

Common complaints include:

  • Sudden account suspensions and payment holds despite no fraudulent activity or chargebacks
  • Lack of direct human support—only scripted responses and chatbots
  • Funds held even after fulfilling orders and providing requested documentation
  • Inability to refund customers during hold periods, affecting both merchants and buyers

Specific cases:

  • One merchant had $12,661 held after two large orders, threatened legal action within 48 hours
  • Another received only half ($16k of $29k) after the 120-day period, with Shopify claiming the remaining $12k is a “glitch”
  • One store faced holds for “not fulfilling orders fast enough” despite supplier being unavailable over a weekend

Merchant responses:

  • Several threaten or pursue legal action through state attorneys general
  • Many vow never to use Shopify Payments, Stripe, or PayPal again
  • Complaints about additional fees charged when using alternative payment providers

Status: Most cases remain unresolved, with merchants experiencing severe cash flow problems and business disruption. The discussion reflects widespread frustration with the platform’s payment practices and lack of transparent communication.

Summarized with AI on October 28. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.
9

This just happened to me, my store was determined to be at a higher risk for customer disputes after a payment was already made by a regular customer. This was my first sale on Shopify since I have been building my business up to move away from Ebay. So now they say I can’t use the Shopify payment gateway and have I over 4k on hold for 120 days or I can refund and use a different gateway.. but Shopify was sure to take their fees first. If they take their fees they should need to pay my payment out. It’s not right that they have access to my money but I don’t. Anyway, I made a complaint to the BBB, I doubt it will do any good. I also told Shopify that I would send them any documents that is needed to release my funds but no response.

New business always have risk and I thought Shopify was a place to start and supported new businesses but it’s not. I should have read some of the pros and cons of doing business with Shopify

Cons of Shopify Payments
Not available in every country: if you’re outside of the listed locations, tough luck.
Must comply with products T&Cs: that means no nudity, etc. And Shopify has been known to suddenly change their mind about certain stores with little notice.
Chargeback fees: according to Shopify, they get billed $15 every time a chargeback occurs. But guess who has to pay for it? Yup, it’s you.
Funds can be suddenly frozen: while they investigate chargeback errors or suspicious account activity. Many users complain about it on the Shopify forums.

1 Like