I tried this but the auto discount got removed from the cart - not sure where I went wrong!
Topic summary
A merchant wants to run a promotion combining a 25% storewide discount with a free gift when orders exceed $129, and needs help making these offers work together in Shopify.
Native Shopify Approach:
- Create the BOGO (free gift) as an auto-apply discount that combines with “Order Discounts”
- Set up the 25% off as an order discount code that combines with “Product Discounts”
- Drawback: customers must manually enter the coupon code and add the gift product to their cart
Third-Party App Solutions:
Multiple app developers recommend their tools:
- BOGOS: Create a native 25% discount code applied to all collections, then use their app for the gift-with-purchase offer (claims automatic combination)
- BOGO+ and Wizz Flash Sale: Use separate apps for the gift promotion and price editing
- Monk: Offers tiered milestone setup where Tier 1 applies 25% off from $0 and Tier 2 adds the free gift at $129
Current Status:
The merchant attempted the native discount combination but encountered issues with the auto-discount being removed from cart. The discussion remains open with multiple solution paths proposed but no confirmed resolution.