What is a button label? What am I supposed to put in this box?
Sorry you are facing this issue, it would be my pleasure to help you.
Welcome to the Shopify community! 
Thanks for your good question.
Please share your site URL,
I will check out the issue and provide you a solution here.
Hey @Soapbar !
Thanks for getting in touch and welcome to the Shopify Community! Very happy to help you out here today.
The button label is the text that would appear on a call-to-action button on your website. Think of when you send and email, and you click ‘send’ the text that reads ‘send’ would be the button label. To help you out, here is our help center guide on how to customize your theme and also our how to customize vintage themes here, our help center is a great resource to utilize when building out your store!
Are you a new seller, or have you been selling before? Have you heard of Shopify Learn courses? Shopify Learn offers free online courses to help your business, you can sign up here at this link. Once you are signed up, you can access a wealth of information to help you and your business to succeed.
If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to reply on this thread. Have a great day!