Which Shopify app do you pay for but only use one feature of?

Shopify Discussion
, , , ,
1

I’ve been auditing my app stack and realised I’m paying for a few apps
where I genuinely only use one feature. Everything else in them I’ve
never touched.

Curious whether others are in the same position:

  • Which app are you paying for but barely using?
  • What’s the one feature you actually need it for?
  • How much is it costing you per month?

Feels like a lot of us are paying suite prices for single features.

2

Hi @Amar_Gul

Could you let me know which app you’re currently using? I’d be happy to take a look and check whether that specific feature can be implemented directly in your Shopify theme. If it can, you may be able to remove the app and save on monthly subscription costs.

Best regards,
Devcoder :laptop:

4

Hello @Amar_Gul Thanks for reaching out to Shopify community with your concern. Well I don’t have any personal store. But being a Shopify partner for my clients I try to avoid using apps as much as possible by doing custom coding.

Also, one needs to evaluate the time and costing it takes to do custom coding for that functionality and to evaluate if that feature is worth paying for. Keeping the pros and cons of these factors one can decide which app is work keeping or removing from the store.

5

The biggest single-feature bill I keep seeing is page builders. Merchants often pay $25 to $40/month just to keep one custom landing page or product page layout running.

A quick audit you can do today:

  • In Shopify admin, export the last 90 days of app charges.
  • Write down the exact feature each paid app provides.
  • Disable the feature in a duplicated theme and check what actually breaks.
  • Ask a theme developer for a fixed-price quote. If the custom build costs less than 8 to 12 months of fees, replacing the app usually makes sense.

Be careful with review, subscription, and search apps. Those often store data or handle backend functions, so they are not as simple to remove as badges, size charts, tabs, or sticky add-to-cart bars.

6
  • Revenue hunt: It was the only app I found that enabled me to efficiently set up a simple “style guide quiz” to help my customers choose the correct scrub cap style out of the 3 we offer. I think the “value” add for the rest of the features is around upselling and recommendations, but I don’t really use it for that.
  • FD Product Groups for image-based variant style selectors that link separate shopify products.
  • Goalify: Upsell Goals - I really just wanted a “milestone” marker in cart to push customers to hit free shipping or bundle threshold. It was the best in terms of customization of the UI in cart.
7

You are not alone, my merchant subscribe a full suite prices for one key feature. You can try to replace the expensive app with a light weight single feature app or small custom scripts and cancel the suite.

8

Hi @Amar_Gul A few months back, before working together, my customer did a full audit and realized they were paying around $80/month across 4 different micro-apps just for basic visual sections on product pages:

  1. Dedicated FAQ App ($15/mo): I literally only used it for a simple collapsible accordion on product pages.
  2. Product Tabs App ($20/mo): Only used it to split description, shipping, and ingredients.
  3. Countdown Timer App ($15/mo): Used it strictly for announcement bars during sales.
  4. Testimonial Slider App ($30/mo): Used it for a custom review grid on the homepage.

Not only were they paying “suite prices” for basic single features, but every single one of those apps was injecting its own JavaScript file into the theme header, which was killing mobile page speed performance.

How our team consolidated:

Instead of paying monthly subscriptions for single section apps, we moved toward using section builder/theme customizer tools like Weaverse.

Because it lets you build and add custom, responsive sections directly inside the Shopify theme editor visually, it completely eliminated the need for 4 of those micro-apps.

  • Saved: ~$80/month in recurring app subscriptions.
  • Bonus: Store speed improved noticeably because we eliminated 4 third-party JS script calls on every page load.

Definitely worth auditing your stack to see how many single-feature apps can be replaced with native theme sections or a single visual section builder.

9

HI @Amar_Gul

I’ve definitely found myself in that situation. Over time, it’s easy to accumulate apps where you only rely on one core feature while the rest of the functionality goes unused.

That’s one reason I’ve started looking for more focused apps instead of all-in-one suites. If an app solves the specific problem well and is priced accordingly, it often provides better value than paying for a large feature set you’ll never use. Regularly auditing your app stack is a good habit. It can uncover opportunities to simplify your store and reduce monthly costs.

10

Hey @Amar_Gul ,

You’re definitely not alone. It’s pretty common to keep an app installed for one feature, even if the rest of the functionality goes unused.

For me, it’s worth reviewing subscriptions every few months to see whether a lighter app or a small theme customization could replace that single feature. In some cases, a simple Shopify Flow automation or a bit of custom code can eliminate the need for a full subscription.

Those small monthly charges don’t seem like much individually, but they can add up quickly when you’re paying for several apps that you’re only partially using. It’s a good reminder to audit your app stack regularly and make sure each subscription is still providing enough value.

Thank You !

11

This one comes up a lot with analytics and profit tools. Triple Whale is the classic example - most stores use maybe 20% of what it does, usually just the summary dashboard, and pay $150-400+ a month for the rest. The problem is the pricing model: almost every tool in that space charges based on GMV or locks core features behind higher tiers, so you end up paying for scale you have not hit yet or features you do not need. Before renewing anything in your analytics stack it is worth asking: what decision did this tool actually help me make in the last 30 days? If the answer is vague, that is the one to cut first.

12

We actually agree with this. It’s something we’ve heard from a lot of Shopify merchants over the years, many apps keep adding more and more features, but most stores only end up relying on a handful while paying for the entire suite.

That’s one of the reasons we built GoProfit the way we did. Instead of trying to be an all-in-one business platform, we focus on helping merchants understand their profitability with the features they actually need - without unnecessary complexity or enterprise-level pricing.

We’d rather keep the app compact, easy to use, and reasonably priced than pack it with features that most merchants will never touch. Of course, every store is different, but we think apps should earn their place in your stack by solving a real problem, not by having the longest feature list.

13

Hello there @Amar_Gul I discovered this too when I did an audit of my apps recently. Several apps remained installed for a single feature that was integral to the workflow, but the majority of functionalities in those apps were never used. It’s worth revisiting your stack every few months to see if Shopify has included any native features which cover that use case. Streamlning apps, where you can, will save you money and your store will be easy to manage.

14

Hello, @Amar_Gul
Hope you are doing well!
Klaviyo. I mainly use it for email automation, but many stores barely scratch the surface of everything else it offers.