Why are my edits replicated across all pages and how can I fix it?

Topic summary

Users are experiencing issues where edits made to one page in their Shopify store are automatically replicated across all other pages. This occurs because multiple pages are using the same template, and changes to a template affect all pages assigned to it.

Root Cause:

  • In Online Store 2.0 themes (like Dawn), editing a template in the theme editor applies changes to all pages using that template
  • By default, new pages are assigned to the “Default page” template

Solution:

  • Create separate page templates for pages requiring different layouts or content
  • Navigate to the theme editor and create new templates following Shopify’s template creation steps
  • Assign the new template to specific pages via the “Theme template” dropdown in the page settings (bottom right)
  • Templates must be created in the currently published theme to appear as options

Key Distinctions:

  • Template editing (theme editor): Changes the layout/structure for all pages using that template
  • Product/page editing (admin): Changes content-specific information for individual items
  • Use metafields to display unique information (like breed-specific details) across products sharing the same template

One user noted that template assignments sometimes revert to “default page” despite changes, suggesting potential saving/persistence issues. An alternative coding solution involves using conditional Liquid tags to restrict app blocks to specific templates.

Summarized with AI on October 29. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

Hi, Thanks for the reply… when adding a new page It only gives an option for Theme Template or Contact.

There are no other options. It is so frustrating, as all I want to do is add a new page that has the same theme, but has different content to the previous.

Simple really

3 Likes