Lately, we seem to be losing every chargeback and it seems very unfair. These are real customers and they don’t seem to be setting out to commit fraud, they just seem lazy or people who become agitated easily. Yesterday I lost a case where a customer ordered the wrong size item, they contacted us an…

Hi, thanks for the reply. Yes, I believe that I am doing all of these things. As another example, last week a customer wasn’t happy with the product. They shipped it back and we refunded them but they also opened a chargeback. We showed the bank that we had issued the refund and the customer still w…

It’s really all crap - you are screwed and Shopify will not lift a finger to help. Shopify has decided to outsource their chargeback process to a 3rd party. So if you call Shopify support to discuss why you lost a chargeback, they can’t help at all. It’s one of the WORST things about Shopify. As a m…

Hello Had a chargeback about a year ago. (Lady wanted to exchange 2 gowns for another size, someone made a mistake in the company and sent the new ones without waiting for the returns AND SHE ASKED FOR A CHARGEBACK WITH 4 GOWNS IN HAND !!) We were in our right to not pay back, but even then, were c…

I agree completely with Bont and all the others here. We are 5-star merchants, with impeccable customer service, follow-up, and communication with our customers.. then criminal customers fully take advantage of this broken system and we are the ones left paying the price. Only thing I’ve found helpf…

I submitted a letter from the customer indicating the charge was legitimate, and I still lost the chargeback. Are the credit card companies not even looking at the response? Do the credit card companies automatically side with the customer?

Actually, we called the credit card company after going through a nonsense chargeback and they told us that Shopify does not give them the message we put in the shop for the customer and the bank. So, no wonder we get charged, it is like we never answered. I contacted Shopify about this but they go…

After a few attempts I’ve been able to get the bank to review it (again) as they initiated the chargeback, not the customer. Shopify keeps telling me they’re “transactional” and don’t get any information etc, but it’s them making the deductions from our accounts.

It is the customer who ask for a chargeback, not the credit card company. Twice it happened to us, and both customers admitted to it. It is time consuming to make a chargeback as they must call the credit card company, be on hold, explain why, etc, etc. And it has to sound serious for them to accept…

Why are we losing all chargeback disputes even with good customer service?

Shopify Discussion

bn2019 May 22, 2023, 2:09am 8

I’ve had the same issue twice. The customer agreed the charge was legitimate and that they received their order, but the card processor seems to ignore any evidence you provide.

Topic		Replies	Views
Why is the chargeback process so frustrating and lacking transparency? Payments + Shipping & Fulfilment shopify-payments	48	768	June 18, 2025
Chargeback - Any chance of winning a dispute? Payments + Shipping & Fulfilment fraud-protect	9	333	October 24, 2024
Need shopify support to contact me regarding chargeback incorrectly granted to customer Payments + Shipping & Fulfilment	10	177	August 5, 2023
#error! Shopify Discussion	9	152	March 16, 2024
Can we file a class action against fraudulent charge backs? Payments + Shipping & Fulfilment third-party-payment-providers	19	386	December 18, 2025

Why are we losing all chargeback disputes even with good customer service?

Related topics