Why is my A record IP address still showing an error despite correct setup?

Topic summary

A Shopify-purchased domain showed an A record error for nearly a week despite being set to IP 23.227.38.65. Email verification was re-triggered successfully, but the DNS error persisted initially.

Troubleshooting steps recommended:

  • Use WHOIS (public database of domain registration/DNS) to check pointing issues.
  • Ensure the A record points to 23.227.38.65 and the Host is [email removed] (root domain), deleting any other A records.
  • Set the CNAME for “www” to shops.myshopify.com. (including the trailing period).
  • If needed, reset DNS settings so only the Shopify A and CNAME records remain.

Clarifications:

  • A record: maps a domain to an IP address.
  • CNAME record: aliases one domain (e.g., www) to another.
  • Host [email removed] represents the root domain without a subdomain.

Outcome: After applying the changes (confirmed via screenshots), support verified the domain is now correctly configured and working. No further DNS issues were identified.

Additional guidance: Consider adding an About Us page to improve conversion rates; resources were provided. Status: Resolved; no outstanding technical questions.

Summarized with AI on January 14. AI used: gpt-5.

Thanks a lot for your help! Yes my site is a work in rogress right now :).