I have the free version of wishlist plus. This coding has been a complete nightmare. I finally got the damn heart to show up, but it’s blue, underlined, and not at all aligned with the cart icon. I have no idea why. Been wasting half the day on this thing and can not for the life of me figure out how to get it to just look normal. Preferably black and hollowed out, and lined up with my other icons.
I’m using the Dawn theme. I followed the apps directions to a T
Sorry you are facing this issue, it would be my pleasure to help you.
Welcome to the Shopify community! 
Thanks for your good question.
Please share your site URL,
I will check out the issue and provide you a solution here.
https://www.crystalsandsunlight.com/ <>
password: seiffa
can you please send this code
a.swym-wishlist {display: flex;align-items: center;border-bottom: none !important;}
that helped with the alignment…its still too close to my other icon…and it’s still underlined with blue.
oh sorry but your heart icon with underline we don’t remove this please change icon if app allow this