Hi, @zacharytipton !
I appreciate these extra details.
Since this issue is only happening with the Lorenza theme, it’s possible that this problem may be tied to the theme specifically.
Lorenza is a third-party theme developed by Fluorescent Design Inc., so I recommend reaching out to them directly to confirm why this may be happening. You can contact these developers by viewing Lorenza in the Shopify Theme Store using this link, and then clicking ‘Support’ on the right hand side of the page.
Please keep me posted on how this goes!