1,027 sessions Only 1 order

New Member
3 0 0

So I was on Etsy for a few years but recently wanted to get off of that platform and start my own online store.


I was doing fairly well on Etsy, while I know traffic is different there, I just feel like I should have had a few more orders by now. I love my product, and Ive always felt it’d be a hit. I was averaging 12 orders a week on Etsy. I can’t figure out what I’m doing wrong here. I’d really like to try and figure it out. Your tips and feedback are appreciated.

Replies 5 (5)
Shopify Partner
713 68 272

Hi @Gabking

Just take a look at your store and I can have some comments for you:

- At first, I want to talk about a reason why your customers buy less from your store than your Etsy channel. 

Because when your customers search for products on Etsy, they can compare the prices between different suppliers. So when they see your product prices are cheaper, they will buy them immediately. 

But when they visit your site, they cannot compare with any stores. Therefore, the solution here is you need to have better offers for your customers.

- Now, I'll talk about your store design:

When you want to have your own store, you also make it look more unique. You are selling POD products. So what makes you look different from other stores is real-life photos. You can have more real-life photos in many ways: have your own products or as your customers for photo reviews. 

I've seen your Instagram account, you can think about having an Instagram gallery to show your product photos. 

Check this app Shoppable Instagram Gallery. This will help you create a gallery and also make it shoppable. 


Hope this helps!

Happy selling, 

AllFetch - eCommerce Order Fulfillment Service - Serving 15.000+ active merchants.
- We offer many solutions to help store owners grow their Shopify businesses.

Click Like and Accept as Solution if you like! Want to customize your store, contact us at support@allfetch.com
Shopify Partner
705 61 198

Hello @Gabking,

I've taken a look at your store and found there are quite a few things which if added can make better conversions.

1. Add 'New Arrivals' section to help customers keep updated on new products.
2. Add product reviews as most of the customers read the review before purchasing the product.
3. Add favicon to your store which is a small square image/logo that appears next to a web address. Favicon helps to strengthen your brand and add a polished look to your website.
4. Optimize your footer with a more professional and functional look. Add pages like About Us, Privacy Policy, Terms of Service, etc to the footer.
5. Add more specific product title/url in product pages.
Creating the perfect SEO product title/url can help the search engine understand exactly what it is you are selling and drive more traffic to your site. So try to keep the product title/url unique and more specific.
6. Add filters in collection pages to help your visitors narrow in on the specific product they're looking for and find products they might be interested in based on certain features (e.g. size, color, category)
7. Add sorting feature in collection pages for changing the order of any product listing whereby users can choose which criteria they want the products to be listed by.

Before you think of ranking you should ensure your pages are found (indexed by Google). You can submit your store content regularly to all the major engines, or consider using a convenient tool like flare by Mansion Ecommerce. flare automatically detects site changes and verifiably informs major search engines like Google & Bing. You can get your free Google Index Score through flare. Plus! Only flare can submit individual URLs to Google & Bing, allowing your prioritized pages to be indexed first and fast.

Hope this was helpful!

Shopify Partner
1070 143 333

Hey @Gabking,

So sorry to hear, it has to be so discouraging. We hear from a lot of store owners A LOT that they get a lot of traffic but no conversions. We’ve created a video walking you through how to do your SEO properly so that you can target your intended audience:

Etsy has their own search that only extends within their own website. With your own store you are now in a much broader pool of search results on Google. Hang in there, with some SEO adjustments you will hopefully start seeing some sales.

Best of luck!

If you have any questions, you can contact us using the information in our signature. We hope our response was helpful, if it was, let us know by giving us a thumbs up!

Join our new Facebook Group for Shopify Dropshippers! Winning products, dropshipping advice & more!

Website | Email | YouTube | TikTok | Facebook

12 0 2

Hi @Gabking,

The theme you are using is the default, basic theme. There are free themes that Shopify provides that are a lot better. If you would like me to design your store please email me at ecomideasbuilder@gmail.com. Otherwise I would suggest the Brooklyn theme.

Feel free to contact me for help regarding store design and set-up!
Email: ecomideasbuilder@gmail.com
Shopify Partner
4161 244 729

Hello @Gabking, I hope you are doing good! your store is password protected, please share the password.



Sachin D | Shopify Growth Expert @ AiTrillion

- Was my reply helpful? Click Like to let me know!
- Was your question answered? Mark it as an Accepted Solution
- 10+ Years of eCommerce experience.
- 1400+ Stores Designed on Shopify.
- All in One Marketing App on Shopify AiTrillion Marketing Automation
- 13+ Shopify Apps launched on app store.