A merchant received a Switzerland order where the customer paid 20.41 CHF for USPS First Class Package International, but Shopify only offered a much more expensive DHL DDP label at purchase time.
The core issue identified is DDP (“Delivered Duty Paid”), meaning duties/import taxes were collected at checkout and must be remitted through a compatible carrier. USPS First Class was not available for this DDP shipment to Switzerland through Shopify, so DHL was shown as the eligible option.
Advice given:
The customer has already paid duties, but not the higher DHL shipping cost, so the merchant would absorb the difference if fulfilling as-is.
Options are to buy the DHL label and ship, or contact the customer, explain the issue, and cancel/refund the order.
To prevent recurrence, disable duties/import tax collection for international markets or update shipping profiles/rates to match DDP-compatible services.
A shipping app with carrier API DDP rate support was suggested if the merchant wants to keep offering DDP.
The issue remains unresolved; the merchant is seeking help deciding what to do.
I got an order to ship to Switzerland. The customer paid 20.41 CHF for a First Class Package. When I actually go to buy the shipping label, it’s completely different. I get this.
Why don’t I get the First Class Package option, why do I only have DHL??? And why is is so much more???
What I’m guessing is that the line at the top of your screenshot is the clue. “DDP labels remit prepaid duties to carrier” means you’re collecting duties and import taxes at checkout, so the label has to be DDP. USPS First Class Package International doesn’t support that, so Shopify only shows carriers that can take the prepaid duties, which is DHL Express here. That’s why the First Class option disappeared.
To stop this happening again, either turn off duties collection at checkout for international markets, or update your international shipping rates so what customers pay at checkout actually covers the DHL DDP cost.
When you enable DDP, your shipping profile/rates need to match carriers and services that can actually handle DDP for the destination. That is your real issue. Your shipping setup allowed the customer to select a shipping service that isn’t compatible with DDP.
USPS First-Class Package International does support DDP to certain countries, but USPS does not currently support DDP to Switzerland, and Shopify Shipping doesn’t support USPS for DDP labels anyway.
DHL is selected, and it says that’s the cheapest option. So I would re-configure the shipping profile to this, or just not do DDP.
The customer already paid the duties at checkout, so that part’s covered and they won’t get charged anything on delivery. The only gap is shipping, they paid for First Class but the DHL label is $64.06, so you’d be covering that difference yourself on this one.
So just buy the DHL label, ship it, and the customer gets a smooth delivery with no surprise fees. Then fix your international rates or turn off duties collection so it doesn’t happen on the next order.
Hope that helps! If it did, a Like and Marking it as Solution goes a long way and helps others find the fix faster too.
Maybe message the customer, explain the shipping cost issue, and offer to cancel with a full refund? Plenty of customers are understanding about this.
For fixing it going forward, turn off duties collection at checkout for your international markets. You’ll find it under Settings, Markets, then open your international market and look for duties and import taxes. That stops Shopify forcing DDP labels, so First Class shows up again.
If you’re not sure what to change or want your international shipping set up properly so this doesn’t happen again, happy to take a quick look for you.
Honestly, I think the only thing you can really do at this point is cancel the order and give them a full refund. Paying more for shipping than the actual product is worth just doesn’t make much sense.
Going forward, I’d probably turn off duties/import taxes at checkout for international orders; otherwise, you might run into the same thing again.
But if you’re worried about conversions and still want to offer DDP, there are shipping apps that support DDP through different carriers. PH Multi-Carrier Shipping Label App is one option you could look at. It pulls the rates directly from the carrier API for supported DDP services, so the rate the customer sees should be pretty much what you pay for the label.