A store owner using a pre-order app faces a display conflict: enabling “continue selling when out of stock” allows pre-orders to function but incorrectly shows out-of-stock items as “in stock” on product pages.
Core Issue:
The Shopify setting treats products as available when “continue selling” is checked
This overrides accurate inventory status displays
User needs to show “0 quantity” or “out of stock” messages while maintaining pre-order functionality
Proposed Solutions:
Use pre-order apps with custom messaging features (Early Bird, K1 PreOrder mentioned)
Apply CSS to hide “in stock” indicators for pre-order products only
Edit theme code to separate display logic from selling functionality
Side Discussion:
Another user attempted to charge for fixing alleged “bugs” in the store’s robots.txt file
Community members warned this appeared to be a scam, as the file was standard
Status: The original inventory display issue remains unresolved, though app-based solutions and theme customization were suggested as workarounds.
Summarized with AI on November 2.
AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.
I’m using a pre order application and I have to check the (continue selling when out of stock) checkbox to make pre order button do its job when clicked. At the same time I’m displaying inventory status on product page but the problem is that if I have an out of stock quantity it display (in stock) because the (continue selling …) check box is selected.
Is there a way to display 0 quantity or out of stock message for out of stock items even if (continue selling …) checkbox is selected ?
Two things. Firstly, and most importantly, I would delete Miaa09’s access to your store. There is no bug in your store. Your robots.txt file is standard. This smells of a scam, or exploitation to try and get money from you to fix the “bugs”.
Secondly, to address your initial question, it would depend on the app you’re using. We built a preorder app for example which has options to show a custom message with your preorder/backorder products, so you can make it clear that the item is not currently in stock.
You may also be able to hide the “In stock” indicator for preorder products only using CSS.
If you’re interested in trying our app (Early Bird), I’d be happy to help you set this up.
I appreciate your concern, the issue was how can I display out of stock or 0 quantity on inventory status even if continue selling when out of stock is checked
Unfortunately, Shopify doesn’t have a built-in setting for this - when Continue selling when out of stock is enabled, the platform treats products as available regardless of inventory levels. You’ll need to edit your theme to separate display logic from selling functionality.
Alternatively, an app like K1 PreOrder can automate this (I’m the founder), handling the Continue selling when out of stock setting automatically during rule activation/deactivation while keeping inventory displays accurate, with scheduling and custom buttons built in. And the inventory status can be modified (for correct status showing) by custom css inside. If this is relevant, you can check K1 PreOrder app in Shopify Store.