Goal: Set up tiered discounts that apply only to selected products or a specific collection (2nd item 15%, 3rd+ 20%, 4th+ 25%), counting multiple different products, not just multiples of the same product.
Solutions proposed:
Discount Bot: “Product Volume discount” supports product/collection/customer tag targeting and a “Limit discount to whole sets (Quantity breaks)” toggle. Provided a test store demo for the Summer Fun collection (password: test123) and offered admin access. Updated cart messaging to nudge shoppers toward the next tier with clear upsell prompts. Screenshots illustrate cart behavior and admin setup.
Regios Automatic Discounts: Claims flexible include/exclude conditions, tiered discounts via a flowchart UI, customizable titles, and a Volume Pricing Table block. Added a product-level demo (password: rtayra) and a Loom walkthrough. Acknowledged feedback to add progress indication and multi-product, same-collection scenarios in future updates.
Other apps: Discounty App (3-day free trial) and a “progress-bar-shipping-gift” app were suggested.
Key considerations: User wants cross-product collection counting and visible progress toward next tier. Discount Bot demonstrates cart prompts; Regios plans improvements.
Status: No final decision; testing is ongoing. Demos and screenshots are central to evaluating the options.
Summarized with AI on December 12.
AI used: gpt-5.
Hi everyone,
I’m looking to implement a tiered discount system in my Shopify store, but I want it to apply only to a specific subset of products. This could either be products that are selected individually or products within a specific collection. Here’s how I would like the discount to work:
The second item gets a 15% discount
From the third item onward, each one gets a 20% discount
From the fourth item onward, each one gets a 25% discount
Is there a way to set this up so that it only applies to a particular set of products or a specific collection, either through Shopify’s native tools or via a third-party app?
@indiear , I suggest you try the Product Volume discount in our app, Discount Bot.
Here’s how you can set up the various tiers that you need.
On the admin, create the tiers that you would like and select the products, collections and/or customer tags you want the discount to apply to.
Depending on whether you need to break on quantity for different tiers or not, you can check or uncheck the “Limit discount to whole sets (Quantity breaks)” checkbox:
For setting up tiered discounts specific to certain products or collections, Regios Automatic Discounts (4.9 stars, 48 reviews) offers a more flexible and powerful solution.
With Regios, you can:
Apply discounts based on specific products, collections, tags, or variants.
Easily set up tiered discounts with our flowchart-style UI, making complex setups intuitive.
Customize the discount title for each quantity break, giving you more control over how discounts appear in the cart and checkout.
Use our “Volume Pricing Table” block to automatically display discounts on product pages, boosting conversion rates.
You can combine an “Include/exclude products” condition with a “Volume/tiered/quantity breaks” discount in our logic builder to easily create multiple tiers with different discount options.
@indiear , If you have a test store, you can install the app there and test it without a subscription. For real stores, you have a 7-day trial available.
Alternatively, please use test store link below. Password: test123.
I’ve set up a tiered discount for the Summer Fun collection:
I would like a demo that shows the ability to add multiple products from the same collection, not the same product multiple times.
Unfortunately, in your demo store/app, there is no indication for the user during purchase of how much is left to reach a certain discount, which makes it less effective in incentivizing the user to buy multiple items.
Unfortunately, in your demo store/app, there is no indication for the user during purchase of how much is left to reach a certain discount, which makes it less effective in incentivizing the user to buy multiple items.
@indiear , one thing you could do is customize the text that shows up when a lower tier discount is applied to incentivize them to move to a higher tier discount.
I’ve updated the cart message for the lower tier discounts in the demo store.
Here’s the up-sell message users see when they have only 2 items in cart from the collection, nudging them toward 3 cart items:
Discounty App is exactly what you need. It can apply tier discounts on different types of products. Additionally, there is a 3-day free trial available. Check out Discounty app!
