I have purchased some warehouse space and am wanting to create my warehouse as a separate location for inventory management purposes. Thus some items will be available in my physical store only and some in warehouse only, but all available online. When a customer purchases an online order and happens to choose an item from the store & another that’s only in the warehouse, store pickup option no longer shows up for them. This is the case whether I have store pickup enabled at the warehouse location or whether I have it disabled. It only wants to allow shipping. Anyone having this issue / know how to solve?
It DOES seem to combine shipping when shipping is enabled from store but not from warehouse; it will ship both from store. One “workaround” that might work would be creating a free shipping method and naming it “Store Pickup” however this causes tax collection complications. My store is located on a state line and many of my local pickup customers mailing addresses are consequently out of state. With my state’s tax laws, I don’t have to collect tax for order shipped out of state. But because this would be a workaround where in reality they DID pick up at store, it’d be a huge tax nightmare if I were to be audited and not actually have collected tax on those orders that were actually picked up from my store. So that workaround doesn’t work 
Ugh