Drop in Conversion Rates GA4 and Google Ads

Topic summary

A merchant reports declining conversion tracking in GA4 and Google Ads after implementing Shopify’s checkout extensibility updates. Their developer used custom event pixels rather than the Google/YouTube app to accommodate separate UK and USA ad accounts.

Potential causes identified:

  • Missing or incorrect code in the new setup
  • Cookie consent compliance: The new Customer Events system enforces user cookie consent by default, whereas the previous integration may have tracked users regardless of consent preferences
  • Incomplete migration of tracking codes to the Customer Events framework

Suggested next steps:

  • Verify the custom pixel code implementation for errors
  • Review cookie consent settings and their impact on tracking
  • Consider implementing Google Consent Mode V2 for improved tracking while respecting privacy regulations
  • Ensure all tracking codes have been properly migrated to Customer Events

The discussion remains open with no definitive resolution yet. One respondent requested additional details about what else changed and the magnitude of the conversion drop.

Summarized with AI on November 2. AI used: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929.

We are experiencing a drop in conversion reporting via GA4 & Google Ads since completing the checkout extensionability updates for Shopify.

Our developer used custom event pixels instead of the Google/Youtube app due to having 2 different ad accounts (UK & USA)
Looking for a second opinion from a developer on how we have everything set up incase there is a missing piece of code somewhere!

Can you share what else you changed? and what is the change in conversions?

Hi @leclaires ,

Theoritically this should not happen unless there is some issue with the integration.

In case the code is correct, then I can think of only one scenario where this can happen.

Its possible that your earlier integration with GA4 and Google ads did not comply with the user’s cookie consent and since now you have migrated to Customer events where the pixel tracking is protected by the user’s cookie consent by defailt.

You can also check Google consent mode V2 for improved tracking based on your company’s privacy policy and local laws.

You guys needed to move the tracking codes into customer events to continue tracking.

https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/promoting-marketing/pixels