Returnable packaging?

AI-generated summary

Whether reusable return packaging is worthwhile depends mainly on the brand’s return rate. For a small brand with few returns, adding packaging cost to every order may not pay off; a mailer with a second sealing strip offers a lower-cost way for customers to reuse it for returns. Reusable packaging may make more sense for categories such as clothing and shoes, where returns are more common.

The reply also suggests reducing avoidable returns by giving customers a short post-purchase window to edit their order, such as changing a size or variant. Before choosing packaging, the brand should check whether its carrier accepts reused mailers with a new label placed over the old one, and review suppliers’ minimum order quantities. No specific packaging choice was made because the brand’s products and return rate were not provided, so the discussion remains open.

Would you recommend packaging that customers can reuse for returns, or would that add too much cost as a small brand?

Hi @iheartmacncheese, Welcome to Shopify community :slight_smile:

I’d decide this from your return rate first, not from the packaging itself.

If only a few orders come back, reusable packaging mostly adds cost to all the orders that never return. A cheaper middle way is a mailer with a second sealing strip, so the customer can reuse the same bag to send it back. It costs a bit more than a plain mailer, but nothing like a proper returnable box.

If returns are a big part of your orders (clothing and shoes often are), it makes more sense, and it makes the return easier for the customer.

Another way to cut returns is to stop some of them before they happen. We’ve seen fewer returns when customers get a short order editing window after purchase, where they can change the size, variant, shipping or discount on their own order.

Before buying packaging, I’d check whether your carrier accepts a reused mailer with a new label over the old one, and what the supplier’s minimum order quantity is.

What do you sell, and roughly how many orders come back (if you want to share)? Happy to think it through with you.

Full disclosure, I build Order Editing Pro, which is free right now and covers post purchase order editing, plus returns and exchanges. The packaging advice above works whatever you use.