Shopify Payments Not Showing Up at Checkout

Hello,

I’ve seen several others encounter this, but haven’t seen a helpful solution.

When I enable Shopify Payments, the only option available at checkout is Paypal. I have circumvented the issue by enabling a third party, but would prefer to use Shopify Payments. I have tried switching back to Shopify Pay from the third party, but the issue persists. I have tried saving different options, but that didn’t change anything. I have tried clearing the cache and using different browsers- still not resolved.

How can I fix the appearance of Shopify Pay options at the checkout?

Thank you for your help