What’s the best loyalty / rewards program I can use with Shopify for my fine jewelry company? I’d like to give repeat customers incentive to keep buying from us. Thanks!
Topic summary
A fine jewelry store owner is seeking recommendations for a Shopify-compatible loyalty/rewards program to incentivize repeat purchases.
Proposed Solutions:
-
Dollarback: Offers cashback rewards using Shopify’s native store credit (real money, not points). Features include customizable cashback percentages by product/collection, customer segmentation for VIP tiers, and display extensions across product pages, cart, and checkout. One featured store achieved ~40% redemption rate versus 18% industry benchmark. Currently offering early bird pricing.
-
Loloyal: Provides points-based rewards for purchases, referrals, birthdays, and social engagement. Includes VIP tier functionality, multi-language support, POS integration, and compatibility with email marketing tools like Klaviyo.
-
99minds: Focuses on premium loyalty experiences with points for sign-ups, purchases (online/in-store), birthdays/anniversaries, and social media actions. Points redeem for discounts, store credits, or exclusive rewards.
-
Credita: Manages loyalty through Shopify’s built-in store credit system with flexible automation rules and activity logging.
Status: The discussion remains open with no confirmed solution selected by the original poster.
@Pkhartjewels we run a Cashback app called “Dollarback” that allows you to setup cashback % / $ amount per product / collection / for the entire store + we also allow you to combine this with Customer segments / tags as well. The main differentiating factor here is that we reward using store credit instead of points (ie - real money, not virtual currency or points).
For example here is a real configuration from one of the stores that’s running our app! As you can see - they have setup 3% for some collections and 5% for others + also segregated based on customer type to give a higher % reward for their VIP customers.
And here are the results they’ve been seeing in just the past month. ~40%+ redemption rate. For context, the industry benchmark is 18%.
Best part is that you can show exactly how much a customer would earn for purchasing a certain product from the store. The app has extensions for the product page, cart page, checkout (plus only), thank you page and also on account pages 
Currently we’re running a limited time early bird offer for brands and will be scaling up the pricing quite soon!
https://apps.shopify.com/dollarback
If you found my answer to be helpful - please mark it as a solution so that others may also find value from the same.
Thank you,
@Pkhartjewels , wanted to chime in here and see if you were able to reach at a solution. If yes - do share so others can also find value from your research.
Btw - we just did a video interview of the brand who’s numbers I’ve shared in my previous post
Best,
Hey @Pkhartjewels!
For a fine jewelry store, I’d recommend checking out Loloyal. It lets you create a flexible loyalty program with things like points for purchases, referrals, birthdays, and even social shares. You can also set up VIP tiers so your repeat customers unlock perks over time, which works really well for building a more exclusive brand experience.
It’s pretty easy to set up and customize, even if you don’t have a developer. And it supports multi-language, POS integration, and works with tools like Klaviyo if you’re doing email marketing too.
Hope this helps a bit! If it does, feel free to mark it as a solution so others can find it too 
Richard from 99minds Gift Card & Loyalty here!
For a fine jewelry brand, a loyalty program should feel premium and create lasting connections with your customers. With 99minds Loyalty Program, you can easily reward your shoppers in multiple ways:
- Sign Up: Give new customers points when they create an account
- Place an Order: Offer points for every purchase made online or in-store
- Birthday and Anniversary Rewards: Surprise customers with bonus points on their special days
- Social Media Actions: Encourage engagement with points for Facebook likes, shares, Twitter follows, YouTube subscribes, and more
Your customers can then redeem these points for discounts, store credits, or exclusive jewelry rewards you set up. Plus, 99minds integrates seamlessly with Shopify, so it all runs smoothly without extra hassle.
Hi there! If you’re searching for a way to manage a loyalty program using Shopify’s built-in store credit—like giving rewards for sign-ups, big purchases, or completed orders—our app Credita might be just what you need.
With it, you can set up flexible rules to issue store credit directly in Shopify, no coding required. Every credit is automatically recorded in a clear activity log, so you can easily track and review your store credit history. The app is quick to install, so you can try it out right away.
If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to reach out—we’re always here to help!
Hello @Pkhartjewels ,
I hope you are well!
I want to inform you that best loyalty/rewards program for repeat customer purchase and incentives can be done with the help of AiTrillion.
With AiTrillion, you can use the best loyalty rewards program which includes VIP tier, points on Reviews, points on Memberships purchase, points on refer a friend and many more with various tools like Membership, Reviews, Affiliate program and many more with single app which are communicating with each other with a single plan.